[SUBW] SUBW Trip report - Helensburgh-Burning Palms-Otford, Sunday September 17

Bruce Stafford bstaffor at med.usyd.edu.au
Fri Sep 22 21:27:12 AEST 2017

SUBW Trip report - Helensburgh-Burning Palms-Otford, Sunday September  
17, 2017.

Walkers: Bruce (leading), Victoria, Cathie, Joyce, Genlei, Zhong,  
Deng, Kasey, Maranna, Zhen, Robert McK, Harriet, Rebecca, Ralf.

Because the walk was listed 3 weeks before the walk day, it was not  
too surprising that there were some dropouts in the week prior due to  
sickness. Still, every time someone had to drop out, I was able to  
replace them off a wait list. So, thanks to those people who gave me  
sufficient notice that they could not come.

Most of us met up for the train at Central, with Harriet getting on at  
Redfern and Cathie at Sutherland. At Helensburgh Station there was the  
usual queue for the toilets and then it was off on the walk proper.
As it was decided to get the 3.15pm train that afternoon from Otford,  
we decided to leave a visit to Metropolitan Tunnel for another trip,  
as it would have eaten significantly into the time we had available  
for the whole walk.

We walked through the station car park and then across Wilsons Creek  
Road straight onto a track which goes beside the fence by the rail  
line, rising very steeply initially (despite this it is used by locals  
as a short cut to the station). Then by a couple of service tracks  
paved with railway ballast, behind the houses fronting Gardiner Place.  
At this point the track meets the fence of the Helensburgh Tip and  
becomes the "Burgh Track".
Not far along this rough track we came to an unpleasant surprise: a  
rotting deer carcass on the track, rather smelly. This upset some of  
our walkers (and I have sent a message to the Minister for the  
Environment of the need to remove it from the walking track). It  
appears to be the victim of the present deer cull taking place in the  
Royal National Park (the Rusa Deer are not native and have been  
causing environmental damage).

After passing the tip the track widens to a fire trail, crossing over  
the present Helensburgh Tunnel and staying level for a while through  
heath land before starting to drop down through wooded country as it  
headed for the Hacking River.
Not too far along there is a track junction - easily missed as it is  
only denoted by just an arrow. Before entering this track I told  
everyone that they should not stop until they reached the river, as  
this was Leech City. We went along that track through a lot of Cabbage  
tree Palms and open woodland and then meandered along until reaching  
the river. It was quite dry along this section, very unusual, but then  
we have had very dry weather the past several weeks. I also noticed  
that the path is becoming more defined, whereas in past years the  
track was not at all obvious. This suggests that it is becoming  
increasingly used as a track to get to Figure 8 Pool from Helensburgh  
Station. Even so  we did not see any other walkers on this track.

So we came to the Hacking River which was exceptionally low due to the  
prolonged dry weather. It was very easy to cross and only Cathie  
managed to get one foot wet in the river.
Then it was on to another track which met Lady Wakehurst Drive after  
100 metres, and then straight across the road to climb up the hill on  
the way to Garawarra Farm. Not far from the top and out of the wind we  
stopped for a needed water break after the steep climb. I also took a  
head count to make sure no one had been taken by man-eating leeches.
 From the top of the grade the track stays fairly level, passing  
through mainly heathland. Noticed that there has been some hazard  
reduction burning here very recently.
Then it was on to Garawarra Farm car park where we noted ahead of us a  
large group obviously headed for Figure 8 Pool but also unfortunately  
taking with them a loud ghetto-blaster. (noted also that there is now  
a park and pay meter there - $12 for parking [on top of the Park Entry  

There was also a sign there stating that the Royal National Park was  
closed each night from 8.30pm to 5am this week for deer shooting.

Fortunately, I would say, a couple of our group needed a loo break in  
the port-a-loos there and that put some distance between us and the  
group with the ghetto-blaster.
Then we went down the final section of the Burgh Track, and  
encountered the new boardwalk section built to stop erosion on the  
track. Halfway along there is a lookout with a good view of both  
Burning Palms Beach and Figure 8 Pool. I told them how to spot rips on  
a beach (see photos), although the beach today looked rather rough its  
whole length. Some waves were breaking against the rock shelf next to  
Figure 8 Pool but didn't look too high.
We continued down past the shacks and the surf club down to the north  
end of Burning Palms Beach. Although it was a sunny day it was also  
cool, about 22 degrees C, so no one intended swimming (and in fact  
there was no one all all in the water).
We found a spot among rocks in the middle of the beach for lunch.

Then it was off to Figure 8 Pool, which for some overseas students  
would be a trip highlight. I noted though that the tide had turned and  
was starting to come in again (in any case it was not a particularly  
low tide at 0.41m). Also, the wind had picked up meaning that the sea  
swell was going to increase, and it did. We clambered round the rocks  
as far as the first point, but it soon became clear that with the  
rising tide and more so the significantly increased swell, that  
further progress was unsafe. Where we had been able to walk on dry  
rocks back in April, was now being hit by waves.
So we had no choice but to backtrack back to the beach. There were (as  
usual nowadays) hordes of tourists there, and on the way back to  
Otford we came across still more heading to Figure 8 Pool (who  
obviously had not checked the tide charts).

After another head count to make sure everyone had got off the rocks,  
we continued along the Coast Track which also has a new boardwalk, and  
provides great views south as far as Wollongong. After the Lomandra  
section we entered Palm Jungle which we were pleased to note was not  
muddy underfoot (due to the dry spell) and appeared to have not been  
too badly affected by the foot traffic. After Palm Jungle though, the  
track starts to climb fairly steeply and does not level out until  
reaching Werrong Lookout, about 400 metres before the junction with  
the Cliff Track (which runs between Garawarra Farm and Otford Lookout  
- still don't know why Wildwalks calls it the "Squeezeway").

We had a brief stop at Werrong Lookout to recover from the climb, and  
then got everyone moving for the last section to Otford Lookout and  
then Otford Station. We walked the next 400 metres to the junction of  
the Coast and Cliff tracks, and waited there until everyone was  
gathered together. Another head count - but only 11 persons, including  
Ralf and Robert accounted for, but still waiting for the other 3 guys.  
After a couple on minutes they still hadn't appeared, and Robert said  
that he didn't notice anyone behind him. Someone suggested that it was  
possible that they might have turned right at the Werrong Lookout by  
mistake and were inadvertently heading back towards Burning Palms.   
Or, were they ahead of us, in which case had they gone the wrong way  
at this track intersection?
I got out my list to check their mobile phone numbers but oops! I had  
not written theirs down! Rebecca then suggested logging in to the SUBW  
website on my phone, but the mobile signal was not good.
Also, time was now starting to run short to get to the 3.15pm train at  
Otford, and we had already wasted several minutes at this spot. Cathie  
recalled that Zhong (one of the three) was continually looking at his  
GPS during the walk and could probably find his way to Otford Station  
if he took the wrong track.
The decision was then made to continue on to the Otford Lookout and  
hope that they were there.

We reached that lookout but the 3 guys were not there. More  
discussion, but by that time we had very little time left to get to  
the 3.15pm train and in fact worked out we were not going to make it.  
Victoria suggested that we should go to Otford Station where we could  
at least get the 3.30pm Wollongong train and change at Thirroul for a  
fast train, and once at the station try to contact the 3 guys again.
We got to Otford Station 5 minutes before that train arrived, and just  
as I started to try to check their mobile numbers again, a message  
came through from Zhong stating that they were on the (3.15pm) train  
and thanks for organising the trip.
So, we got the 3.30pm train which took us all stations to Thirroul.  
Not knowing the area, we were (of course!) at the wrong end of the  
train for the stairs over to the platform for the Sydney-bound train,  
which was arriving just as we were still on the stairs. We rushed to  
get this train and just made it. It's next stop was Helensburgh as it  
was an express train.
It got back to Sydney at 5.15pm, an hour later than we had planned.  
Still, better than being 2 hours later which is what would have  
happened if we had had to wait for the 5.15pm train from Otford.
(I have previously taken up with the Minister for Transport the issue  
of Otford and Stanwell Park only having a 2 hourly train service on  
weekends, and I will do so again).

The walk was enjoyable in fine mild weather and everyone liked it  
despite not being able to get all the way to Figure 8 Pool, and the  
muck-up with the trains at the end and the 3 guys separating from the  
group. (I did let them know later that I was not happy about that).

The next suitable sunday for a lunchtime visit to Figure 8 Pool is  
15th October, although even then the "low" tide is 0.52m, even higher  
than it was on our walk. The next suitable sunday after that is not  
until New Year's Eve!

Two lessons to be learned from this trip:
1. Always stick with the trip leader, even if you think you know the  
way. Walks do not always follow the route shown by a GPS, and the  
Cowan-Brooklyn walk is one such walk (see my trip report of that of  
Aug 20, 2016 (https://www.subw.org.au/2016/08/20/cowan-to-brooklyn-6/)
2. If you do find yourself ahead, stop at the first track junction you  
reach and wait for the others to catch up.

Incidentally, despite passing through Leech City next to the Hacking  
River, no one on the walk reported any leeches. Possibly due to the  
dry weather, but also maybe due to people not stopping on that section  
of track.

There is another track running off the Cliff Track, just 300 or so  
metres back from the junction with the Coast track. It's called the  
Lilyvale Track and once provided access to the former Lilyvale station  
located between Helensburgh and Otford. It was closed by the transport  
bean-counters in 1983. Even so this track might be worth exploring  
because it comes out at Lady Wakehurst Drive not too far from the end  
of the Hacking River Fire Trail which leads back to Helensburgh  
Station (and part of which was the first part of our walk). Maybe an  
exploratory walk for sometime next year.

My photo link:  

Ralf's photos (which include me!):  

Bruce Stafford

More information about the SUBW mailing list